"As a complete collection, Gibbard comes off as a sort of lo-fi Brian Wilson, with inventive choices of instrument and sounds. Whether it is a tuneless guitar or a toy piano (on the gorgeous cover of the Magnetic Field's "Why I Cry"), Gibbard makes great use of found instruments. There is a sweetness even in the most desolate lyrics. There is no pretension to these songs; it's just a guy playing for himself in a room somewhere, keeping out the little college town outside."  (PopMatters)

"All-Time Quarterback! is a side project of Death Cab for Cutie frontman Ben Gibbard. Naturally, this album sounds like the Cab de Death, recorded in somebody's bedroom on a four-track. Gibbard, the indie rock vocal twin of Pet Shop Boy Neil Tennett (listen to DCFC's "Movie Script Ending," and you'll hear what I'm talking about), delivers a collection of bare bones, lo-fi melancholy pop tunes. But isn't that what Gibbard does best?"  (Impact Press)

"Though unavoidably Death Cab-ish, due to Death Cab's unique sound heavily revolving around Gibbard's voice, ATQ separates itself from DCFC with a lot more lo-fi prowess that basks in simplicity, as well as Gibbard's fun with toy keyboards and an old guitar. I'll give it a B."  (In Music We Trust)

Back to top